This website uses technologies such as cookies to provide you a better user experience. To learn more refer to our Privacy Policy .

Top
Pre-Rookie Card Wrestling Cards from the 1990's
Sort By
Listings
 
Attributes
Players
Teams
Item Conditions
Sellers
Sold Out
Listing Format
Browse
Skip Navigation Links.
Wrestling (712)
1990's (712)
1999 (235)
1998 (95)
1997 (112)
1996 (31)
1995 (27)
1994 (26)
1993 (7)
1992 (104)
1991 (41)
1990 (34)
Listings 1 - 100 of 712
1995 BBM Pro Wrestling - [Base] #34

Sabu [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$1,129.99
1999 Topps WCW Embossed - Authentic Signatures #_DATA

Dave Taylor

$318.17
1995 BBM Pro Wrestling - [Base] - 1997 2nd Printing #34

Sabu [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$283.90
1999 Comic Images WWF SmackDown! Chromium - [Base] #30

The Hardy Boyz With Michael Hayes [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$228.90
1996-98 WWF Magazine Cards - [Base] #19

Triple H [PSA 9 MINT]

$228.35
1997 Panini WWF Superstars Album Stickers - [Base] #120

The Rock, Rocky Maivia, Owen Hart [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$52.12
1997 Cardinal World Wrestling Federation Trivia Game - [Base] #_MANK

Mankind [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$173.90
1997 Cardinal World Wrestling Federation Trivia Game - [Base] #_ROMA

Rocky Maivia [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$159.60
1995 BBM Pro Wrestling - [Base] #34

Sabu

$84.20
1996 BBM Pro Wrestling - [Base] #62

Rob Van Dam

$75.00
1997 Panini WWF Superstars Album Stickers - [Base] #122

Rocky Maivia, The Rock, Bret Hart [SGC 7 NM]

$49.70
1994-2001 JusToys Bendables Figure Cards - [Base] #_STCO

Steve Austin

$57.90
1996-98 WWF Magazine Cards - [Base] #122

The Sophomore Jinx? [Poor to Fair]

2 from
$38.49
1996-98 WWF Magazine Cards - [Base] #141

Rocky Maivia, The Rock [Noted]

$115.24
1995 BBM Pro Wrestling - [Base] - 1997 2nd Printing #32

Wild Pegasus [PSA 9 MINT]

$114.10
1998 Bandai New Japan Pro Wrestling - [Base] #89

Kevin Nash [PSA 9 MINT]

$114.10
1997 Cardinal World Wrestling Federation Trivia Game - [Base] #_HUHH

Triple H [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$114.10
1991 Championship Marketing WCW - [Base] #14

The Four Horsemen [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$114.10
1995 Panini WWF Superstars Album Stickers - [Base] #186

Triple H [CSG 7.5 Near Mint+]

$52.12
1995 Panini WWF Superstars Album Stickers - [Base] #184

Triple H [CSG 7.5 Near Mint+]

$52.12
1995 Panini WWF Superstars Album Stickers - [Base] #181

Hunter Hearst Helmsley [CSG 7.5 Near Mint+]

$52.12
1997 Cardinal World Wrestling Federation Trivia Game - [Base] #_ROMA

Rocky Maivia [BGS 7.5 NEAR MINT+]

$111.79
1995 WWF Magazine Cards - [Base] #62

Hunter Hearst Helmsley [EX to NM]

3 from
$58.04
1998 Bandai New Japan Pro Wrestling - [Base] #61

The Road Warriors [SGC 9 MINT]

$103.74
1997 Cardinal World Wrestling Federation Trivia Game - [Base] #_ROMA

Rocky Maivia [BGS 6.5 EX‑MT+]

$102.59
1992 Topps WCW U.K. - [Base] #43

Big Van Vader [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$98.00
1997 Panini WWF Superstars Album Stickers - [Base] #122

Rocky Maivia, The Rock, Bret Hart [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$93.40
1997 Panini WWF Superstars Album Stickers - [Base] #122

Rocky Maivia, The Rock, Bret Hart [PSA 5 EX]

$93.40
1997 Cardinal World Wrestling Federation Trivia Game - [Base] #_ROMA

Rocky Maivia [PSA 4 VG‑EX]

$93.40
1992 Merlin Gold Series WWF Series 2 - [Base] #78

Repo Man

$92.25
1992 Merlin Gold Series WWF Series 2 - [Base] #88

Crush [EX to NM]

$92.25
1992 Merlin Gold Series WWF Series 2 - [Base] #63

Papa Shango

$92.25
1992 Merlin Gold Series WWF - [Base] #15

Papa Shango [Good to VG‑EX]

$92.25
1999 Comic Images WWF SmackDown! Chromium - [Base] #30

The Hardy Boyz With Michael Hayes [HGA 9 MINT]

$92.24
1999 Comic Images WWF SmackDown! Chromium - [Base] #30

The Hardy Boyz With Michael Hayes [PSA 9 MINT]

4 from
$92.24
1997 Panini WWF Superstars Album Stickers - [Base] #113

Rocky Maivia, The Rock [SGC 7 NM]

$87.65
1998 Topps WCW/nWo - [Base] #27

Eddy Guerrero [PSA 9 MINT]

3 from
$47.39
1992 Merlin Gold Series WWF Series 2 - [Base] #85

Tatanka

$80.75
1992 Merlin Gold Series WWF - [Base] #95

Tatanka

$80.75
1992 Merlin Gold Series WWF - [Base] #84

Repo Man [EX to NM]

$80.75
1999 Crazy Planet WCW Stickers - [Base] #_KENA

Kevin Nash

3 from
$4.21
1995 BBM Pro Wrestling - [Base] - 1997 2nd Printing #112

Wayne Shamrock [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$79.60
1997 Panini WWF Superstars Album Stickers - [Base] #120

The Rock, Rocky Maivia, Owen Hart [PSA 4 VG‑EX]

$76.15
1997 Panini WWF Superstars Album Stickers - [Base] #115

The Rock, Rocky Maivia [PSA 4 VG‑EX]

$76.15
1997 Panini WWF Superstars Album Stickers - [Base] #118

The Rock, Rocky Maivia [PSA 9 MINT]

$76.15
1992 Merlin Gold Series WWF Series 2 - [Base] #15

Summer Slam - Crush, Repo Man

$75.00
1995 BBM Pro Wrestling - [Base] #112

Wayne Shamrock

$34.75
1992 London Publishing WCW Magazine - [Base] #12

Cactus Jack [PSA 4 VG‑EX]

$70.40
1999 Topps WCW/nWo Nitro - [Base] #13

Rey Mysterio Jr. [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$35.90
1992 Merlin Gold Series WWF Series 2 - [Base] #43

Crush

$69.25
1992 Merlin Gold Series WWF Series 2 - [Base] #30

Papa Shango

$69.25
1992 Merlin Gold Series WWF - [Base] #93

Papa Shango [EX to NM]

$69.25
1997 Panini WWF Superstars Album Stickers - [Base] #124

The Rock, Rocky Maivia [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$58.90
1997 Panini WWF Superstars Album Stickers - [Base] #123

The Rock, Rocky Maivia

26 from
$8.30
1997 Panini WWF Superstars Album Stickers - [Base] #114

The Rock, Rocky Maivia

16 from
$5.20
1992 Merlin Gold Series WWF - [Base] #65

Papa Shango

$57.75
1998 Topps WCW/nWo - [Base] #32

Rey Mysterio Jr. [PSA 9 MINT]

4 from
$52.00
1997 Cardinal World Wrestling Federation Trivia Game - [Base] #_HUHH

Triple H [PSA 9 MINT]

3 from
$47.98
1991 WWF Sours Gum Wrappers - [Base] #_NADI

Natural Disasters

$20.58
1992 Merlin WWF Album stickers - [Base] #161

Razor Ramon

2 from
$20.58
1994-2001 JusToys Bendables Figure Cards - [Base] #_MANK.2

Mankind (White Shirt) [EX to NM]

$20.58
1994-2001 JusToys Bendables Figure Cards - [Base] #_CHJE

Chris Jericho

$20.58
1994-2001 JusToys Bendables Figure Cards - [Base] #_KESH

Series 7 - Ken Shamrock [Noted]

$20.58
1992 Merlin Gold Series WWF - [Base] #52

Earthquake of Natural Disasters [EX to NM]

$57.74
1998 Topps WCW/nWo - [Base] #69

Chris Jericho [PSA 9 MINT]

$57.74
1997 Panini WWF Superstars Album Stickers - [Base] #120

The Rock, Rocky Maivia, Owen Hart [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

2 from
$26.24
1997 Panini WWF Superstars Album Stickers - [Base] #154

Triple H, Bret Hart [PSA 9 MINT]

$26.24
1998 Bandai New Japan Pro Wrestling - [Base] #89

Kevin Nash

3 from
$23.25
1999 WWF Hot Shots Attitude Stickers - [Base] - Australian #101

Shane McMahon

$55.17
1999 Navarrete Gladiadores de la WCW/nWo - [Base] #35

Kevin Nash

$55.17
1999 Navarrete Gladiadores de la WCW/nWo - [Base] #96

Kevin Nash

$55.17
1999 Navarrete Gladiadores de la WCW/nWo - [Base] #93

Chris Benoit

$55.17
1999 Navarrete Gladiadores de la WCW/nWo - [Base] #90

Eddy Guerrero

$55.17
1999 Navarrete Gladiadores de la WCW/nWo - [Base] #17

Kevin Nash

$55.17
1999 Navarrete Gladiadores de la WCW/nWo - [Base] #7

Chris Benoit

$55.17
1997 Panini WWF Superstars Album Stickers - [Base] #113

Rocky Maivia, The Rock [PSA 6 EX‑MT]

2 from
$53.15
1993 Merlin WWF Stickers - [Base] #102

Adam Bomb

$52.00
1992 Merlin Gold Series WWF Series 2 - [Base] #14

Summer Slam - Crush, Repo Man

$52.00
1992 Merlin Gold Series WWF Series 2 - [Base] #69

Brian Knobbs of the Nasty Boys

$52.00
1992 Merlin Gold Series WWF - [Base] #59

Blake

$52.00
1995 BBM Pro Wrestling - [Base] #32

Wild Pegasus

2 from
$24.74
1996-98 WWF Magazine Cards - [Base] #153

United They Stand, Divided They Fall

2 from
$18.25
1992 Merlin Gold Series WWF Series 2 - [Base] #28

Money Inc.

3 from
$5.19
1992 Merlin WWF Album stickers - [Base] #293

Papa Shango

$51.99
1998 Topps WCW/nWo - Stickers #S9

The Giant, Big Show [PSA 9 MINT]

$51.99
1999-05 Danbury Mint 22K Gold WWF/E - [Base] #55

Stacy Keibler

$51.37
1999-05 Danbury Mint 22K Gold WWF/E - [Base] #26

Stephanie McMahon-Helmsley [Uncirculated]

$51.37
1999-05 Danbury Mint 22K Gold WWF/E - [Base] #26

Stephanie McMahon-Helmsley

$51.37
1996-98 WWF Magazine Cards - [Base] #6

Two Dudes With Attitudes

$50.85
1995 WWF Magazine Cards - [Base] #85

Sid

2 from
$4.21
1996-98 WWF Magazine Cards - [Base] #115

The Guiding Light! [Poor to Fair]

$48.55
1992 Merlin WWF Album stickers - [Base] #56

Crush

3 from
$3.23
1997 Panini WWF Superstars Album Stickers - [Base] #114

The Rock, Rocky Maivia [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$47.40
1997 Panini WWF Superstars Album Stickers - [Base] #122

Rocky Maivia, The Rock, Bret Hart [PSA 7 NM]

$47.40
1997 Cardinal World Wrestling Federation Trivia Game - [Base] #_ROMA

Rocky Maivia [PSA 5.5 EX+]

$47.40
1992 London Publishing WCW Magazine - [Base] #24

Big Van Vader [Good to VG‑EX]

2 from
$3.70
1997 Panini WWF Superstars Album Stickers - [Base] #153

Triple H

12 from
$11.93
1998 Topps WCW/nWo - [Base] #19

Chris Jericho [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$51.99
1999 Comic Images WWF SmackDown! Chromium - [Base] #58

The Rock vs. Mick Foley [BGS 9.5 GEM MINT]

$46.25
1992 Merlin Gold Series WWF - [Base] #36

High Energy

$46.25
<< 1 2 3 4 5 >>
Go to page
Page 1 of 8